А как же оно тикает?
11,299,814
15,067
|
Пиджак_9 ( Слушатель ) |
| 23 апр 2020 23:20:54 |
ответ
новая дискуссия Дискуссия 413
Коллеги, спасибо, докладываю, что рецензия от журнала получена.
Reviewers' comments on your work have now been received. You will see that they are advising against publication of your work. Therefore I must reject it.
For your guidance, I append the reviewers' comments below. Please note that you are allowed to submit a revised version of this manuscript as a new submission, if you are willing to take the reviewer comments into account.
IReviewers' comments:
Reviewer #1: This manuscript is not acceptable for publication at this time. Please include details about the configuration of your device. Please provide a more exhaustive reference list and include recent references published within the past 2-3 years (For instance, recent studies using 10GHz or 24GHz radar) and compare your results. RF fields above 10 GHz are absorbed at the skin surface, with very little of the energy penetrating into the underlying tissues. This study using continuous wave transmitter of 433.82 MHz, such low frequency which may result in adverse health effects. Please ensure there is an Ethical approval for this study and should be reported.
Reviewer #2: This paper presents a very interesting investigation of the phenomenon of radio frequency anisotropy of electrolyte solution. The experiments described in the paper will certainly determine a lot of interest and discussion from other researchers.
The paper can be accepted for publication but, in my opinion, more details must be given, in order to better understand several choices.
For example, in order to better understand the PCG result given in Fig. 3, it will be useful to indicate the position and the distance of the transmitting and receiving antennas from the human body. Moreover, why two RF signals are necessary in the receiving device shown in Fig. 1? It is not possible to obtain a similar result using only one RF amplifier? Why the amplitude detectors are logarithmic? Is it possible to use linear amplitude detectors?
Concerning the results shown in Figs. 7 and 8, is it possible that the used electronic device had a "contribution"? The first result given in Fig. 7 corresponds to the impulse response of a stable electronic device with two complex conjugate poles of its transfer function.
Мне особенно понравились вопросы зачем нужно два РЧ сигнала на приеме.
Reviewers' comments on your work have now been received. You will see that they are advising against publication of your work. Therefore I must reject it.
For your guidance, I append the reviewers' comments below. Please note that you are allowed to submit a revised version of this manuscript as a new submission, if you are willing to take the reviewer comments into account.
IReviewers' comments:
Reviewer #1: This manuscript is not acceptable for publication at this time. Please include details about the configuration of your device. Please provide a more exhaustive reference list and include recent references published within the past 2-3 years (For instance, recent studies using 10GHz or 24GHz radar) and compare your results. RF fields above 10 GHz are absorbed at the skin surface, with very little of the energy penetrating into the underlying tissues. This study using continuous wave transmitter of 433.82 MHz, such low frequency which may result in adverse health effects. Please ensure there is an Ethical approval for this study and should be reported.
Reviewer #2: This paper presents a very interesting investigation of the phenomenon of radio frequency anisotropy of electrolyte solution. The experiments described in the paper will certainly determine a lot of interest and discussion from other researchers.
The paper can be accepted for publication but, in my opinion, more details must be given, in order to better understand several choices.
For example, in order to better understand the PCG result given in Fig. 3, it will be useful to indicate the position and the distance of the transmitting and receiving antennas from the human body. Moreover, why two RF signals are necessary in the receiving device shown in Fig. 1? It is not possible to obtain a similar result using only one RF amplifier? Why the amplitude detectors are logarithmic? Is it possible to use linear amplitude detectors?
Concerning the results shown in Figs. 7 and 8, is it possible that the used electronic device had a "contribution"? The first result given in Fig. 7 corresponds to the impulse response of a stable electronic device with two complex conjugate poles of its transfer function.
Мне особенно понравились вопросы зачем нужно два РЧ сигнала на приеме.
Чорт с ними.
ОТВЕТЫ (5)
|
adolfus ( Слушатель ) |
| 25 апр 2020 02:24:49 |
Цитата: Пиджак_9 от 23.04.2020 23:20:54
Реальная практика показывает, что незапланированные и неодобренные ПП результаты публиковть в иностранных изданиях с импакт-фактором бессмысленно. Вас обосрут прикормленные рецензенты и издание откажет. Пока вы будете расчесывать обиду нужные люди опубликуют нечто похожее, что полностью перечеркнет ваш приоритет. Новые результаты нужно публиковать в отечественных изданиях, входящих в перечень ВАК. По крайней мере, за вами гарантируется приоритет.
|
|
Пиджак_9 ( Слушатель ) |
| 25 апр 2020 09:42:07 |
Цитата: adolfus от 25.04.2020 02:24:49
Ну что Вы, какие обиды, тем более "расчесанные". Какой приоритет? Разве он может быть у человека из славянской цивилизации, которая совершает пролонгированный суицид? Какие "отечественные издания", когда вчера отечество есть, а завтра оно самоликвидировалось. Пусть пользуются... Беда не в этом, беда в том, что они ничего не поняли, люди из сверкающего Града на Холме.
|
|
adolfus ( Слушатель ) |
| 25 апр 2020 12:15:42 |
Цитата: Пиджак_9 от 25.04.2020 09:42:07
Все они поняли, просто если в чужой работе есть хоть какая вероятность монетизации, ее будут валить, чтобы свои успели застолбить приоритет.
|
slavae ( Слушатель ) |
| 25 апр 2020 12:36:27 |
Цитата: Пиджак_9 от 25.04.2020 09:42:07
Ну да, чтобы они поняли, надо в очередной раз стукнуться лбом в закрытые ворота, из-за которых факи показывают.
|
|
Пиджак_9 ( Слушатель ) |
| 25 апр 2020 12:51:48 |
Цитата: slavae от 25.04.2020 12:36:27
Ну, а если не стукаться, то все пойдет коту под хвост, тихо-тихо так. У нас ничего, кроме трупной зелени, уже не вырастает (в частности, на Украине).